Monday, April 28, 2008



Are We Being Hypocritical?

This is a question asked by Trudie Skyler (wife of Sting - the entertainer). The Daily Mail (a British Tabloid) answers the question in the affirmative in the headline of their article.

However, I can't extract enough information to figure out if, Ms. Skyler actually acknowledged hypocrisy or what the specific charge was. She does acknowledge wanting to curtail use of Genetically Modified products but that's not quite the same thing as having a large carbon footprint (which Sting acknowledges). This is way too muddled to come to a conclusion but it's interesting that Sting's wife seems to have asked herself this question during a press event.

Wednesday, April 16, 2008



Is Hypocrisy a weak term?

Roger Simon, liberal turned not-so liberal (conservative in some areas), says that Mr. Simon was

"was struck by the amazing size of David Geffen's yacht and this morning we injected a photo into the story..."

and concludes [actually an interim conclusion] that

"...We are of course here at a level that makes hypocrisy a weak term. Sure, Geffen and Huffington (with her umpteen thousand square foot home ameliorated by a Prius) are hypocritical in the sense that "hypocrisy is the homage that vice pays to virtue," but there is something more complicated afoot."

I think Mr. Simon is saying that because Mr. Geffen is an advocate of reducing greenhouse emissions, he is a hypocrite.

Well there may be something to that but Mr. Simon does not cite any source noting Geffen's advocacy on that point and I couldn't find anything decisive myself when I browsed a few times.

Not guilty by lack of half the evidence.

Incidentally Geffen apparently is only a part owner of the yacht. The other owner is Larry Ellison (CEO of The Oracle Corporation, Inc.).

The yacht, named 'Rising Sun' is said (by Wikipedia) to be about 450' ft long and is one of the world's longest yachts (however, Ann and I have been on cruise ships that are over twice this length, specifically the Golden Princess and the Diamond Princess).

This subject came up because an admirer of Senator Obama had posted some information on what the Senator had said about Pennsylvania on a website and the owner of the website was on Geffen's yacht at the time and didn't review the posting for a few days.

Friday, April 11, 2008


Naval Officer who worked in prostitution ring taught leadership and ethics at the Naval Academy


Here is the first part of a newspaper article today on the subject:


A Navy officer who taught a leadership and ethics course at the Naval Academy faces dismissal after she testified Thursday that she moonlighted as an escort for the so-called D.C. Madam.

Lt. Cmdr. Rebecca C. Dickinson, 38, admitted in federal court Thursday that she performed sex acts with men in exchange for money as a call girl for Deborah Jean Palfrey (who is in the image above holding what was purported to be a client list) from October 2005 until April 2006.

I don't know for sure what she taught at the leadership and ethics course but its a safe bet that she told the midshipmen not to do anything reasonably perceivable as unethical.

Well, there you go, a true case of hypocrisy. The damage will be very significant for LCDR Dickinson. She will likely lose rank and be discharged under less than honorable conditions. This will decrease, maybe eliminate whatever pension rights she might have accrued (she has been in the service since 1986 and has been a commissioned officer since 1993).

The damage to society is probably much less. There will likely be extra scrutiny provided to other Naval Academy instructors and other minor effects.

Thursday, April 10, 2008




Who is the Hypocrite on Free Trade?

Who isn't?

In the past few weeks, there have been some hypocrisy charges in the matter of the Free Trade Agreement with Columbia (FTA-C).

One set of charges is that opponents of the FTA-C, including representative Nancy Pelosi, the speaker of the US House of Representatives and Senator Harry Reid, the President of the US Senate and various labor organizations realize that the FTA-C is good for the US but oppose it anyway because the public mistakenly blames various problems on NAFTA. Part of the reason for this is said to be that elected officials (like Pelosi and Reid) have been demonizing NAFTA for years.

Another set of charges is that individuals in the campaigns of Senators Obama and Clinton actually support free trade agreements but pretend not to in order to keep working for the candidates they support. A interesting variety of this is that the Obama campaign accused the Clinton campaign of hypocrisy even though Obama advisers have basically done similar things.

This is pointed out at the link.

Assuming the Obama campaign realizes this, then yes, they are being hypocrites in accusing the Clinton campaign of hypocrisy.

This is the first case I can recall of a double reverse hypocrisy. Cool.

FWIW:

bloggress Wonkette charged Mark Penn with hypocrisy in talking to Columbia about promoting the FTA-C, while in a leadership role in an anti-NAFTA Clinton campaign; and,

The leftwing MotherJones magazine reported on Obama senior adviser telling Canada that when Obama denounced NAFTA, he (Obama) didn't really mean it.